Thursday, January 30, 2014

"Land of the free except for Negroes?"

This is a portion of a quote from President John F Kennedy after he realized that the United States had to stop presenting itself as a symbol of freedom while it promoted racial inequality within. He said: "We preach freedom around the world, ... but are we to say to the world, and much more importantly, to each other, that this is a land of the free except for Negroes?"

Birmingham
Firemen hose demonstrators

In the spring of 1963, racial protests took place in cities across the South. At one point in June there were more than 15,000 arrests. The turning point occurred in Birmingham, Alabama. In May, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. had black schoolchildren march on the streets to protest and the police chief unleashed his forces against the young marchers. He had a notorious temper and he saw what were in fact relatively low key protests as a threat to his ‘rule’ in Birmingham. He set police dogs on to the protesters and suddenly Birmingham got national attention (History Learning Site). The images of children being assaulted with nightsticks, high-pressure fire hoses and attack dogs made people around the world sick. This series of events led to President Kennedy endorsing the movement and making the statement quoted above. 


Civil Rights Act of 1964

Lyndon B. Johnson signs the Civil Rights Act of 1964. 


Kennedy presented a Civil Rights Act but was assassinated prior to it being passed. Only five days after taking office Lyndon B. Johnson called on Congress to pass the civil rights bill as a memorial to Kennedy. He said: “We have talked long enough about equal rights in this country. It is now time to write the next chapter and write it in the books of law.” The Civil Rights Act prohibited racial discrimination in employment, hospitals and schools, and privately owned establishments like restaurants, hotels and theaters. It also banned discrimination based on sex. Johnson may have had alternative motives, like getting the black vote of the South for Republicans, but sometimes getting the right thing even if it is for the wrong reasons is a victory. 

Changing Times

During the 1960s the Supreme Court continued the push toward equality by overturning multiple Jim Crow Laws. In Loving v. Virgina it declared laws prohibiting interracial marriage unconstitutional. In Jones v. Alfred H. Mayer Co., the Court ruled that discrimination in the rental or sale of housing was unconstitutional. This was a series of actions that moved the responsibility of enforcing the Bill of Rights to the states and made them accountable if they did not do so. 
Similar Themes Seen Today
http://www.people-press.org/
Recently we have seen a number of civil rights victories in rapid succession. On the forefront has been the expanded acceptance of same-sex couples and unions. Perhaps more so than any other civil rights movement in the past, this movement has seen rapid movement over the last 10 years. In 2003, as the debate over same-sex marriage intensified, Massachusetts became the first state to allow same-sex
http://www.washingtonpost.com/
marriage, a 56% majority of Americans felt that allowing gays and lesbians to marry would undermine the traditional American family, while 39% disagreed. Today, 46% say same-sex marriage would undermine the traditional family while slightly more (51%) disagree. (PewResearch 1)  The acceptance rate of same sex marriage has risen over 15% in this time period. Most of the people that have changed their views have stated that knowing someone gay or lesbian personally has led them to see how ridiculous it is to discriminate against them. In contrast, there was widespread rejection of homosexuality in predominantly Muslim countries, as well as in Africa, Russia and parts of Asia. In most of the Middle East, including Egypt and Jordan, more than nine in 10 people said homosexuality should be rejected. That was also the case in most of Africa, including Kenya, Uganda and Nigeria (Morello).

Looking Forward
It is my hope that this trend of rapid acceptance will continue to evolve. I believe that with social media and a youth that has a strong desire to become involved and force change that the period of time it takes for opinions to change will continue to diminish. That not only racism will no longer be tolerated but sexism and bigotry against any religion, belief or sexual preference. It is amazing to me that people want to revolve their daily thoughts or voting tendencies around what makes other people unhappy. Ideally this comes about because people are reasonable but if it is a political ploy to get my vote then I would accept that as well. Progress by any means is not a bad thing just as time has told us from that sad day in Birmingham. Progress can come out of a horrible incident.

Works Cited

"Birmingham 1963." Birmingham 1963. History Learning Site, n.d. 
    Web. 31 Jan. 2014. 

Emblem, Tracy. "Amending the Civil Rights Act of 1964 Would 
    Give Equality to All People." San Diego Gay and Lesbian News. 
    N.p., 25 May 2010. Web. 31 Jan. 2014.

"Growing Support for Gay Marriage: Changed Minds and 
    Changing Demographics." Pew Research Center for the People 
    and the Press RSS. N.p., 20 Mar. 2013. Web. 30 Jan. 2014. 

Morello, Carol. "Acceptance of Gays in Society Varies Widely."  
    Washington Post. The Washington Post, 04 June 2013. Web. 31 
    Jan. 2014. 

Thursday, January 23, 2014

A Nation's Treatment of its Own Citizens Should Be Subject to Outside Evaluation

This was the core principle of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. In 1948, Eleanor Roosevelt chaired a committee that drafted this document which identified a range of rights to be enjoyed by people everywhere. These rights include freedom of speech, religious toleration, and protection against arbitrary government, as well as social and economic entitlements which article 25 stated:

Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control. Motherhood and childhood are entitled to special care and assistance. All children, whether born in or out of wedlock, shall enjoy the same social protection.

Many of these social and economic entitlements are still seriously debated today. The most recent example is the response to President Obama's Affordable Health Care Act which provides medical coverage for millions of previously uninsured citizens. It is sad that something that made sense 65+ years ago is still under debate today.

Lack of Enforcement
The United Nations originally wanted to specify some form of enforcement mechanism in the act but this was strongly opposed by both the United States and the Soviet Union. Both powers refused outside interference with their internal affairs. They also did not want limitations on their ability to conduct foreign policies however they saw fit. Eleanor Roosevelt saw this act as a combination of civil and political liberties with the social conditions of freedom outlined in her husband's Economic Bill of Rights but without these in place the United States did not partially ratify the document until it was split into two covenants: Civil and Political (which took until 1992) and Economic, Social, and Civil which sadly has still not been approved.

Fears of Socialism
One of the main fears is something heard far too often today. It is this theory that if the government provides these rights then it is a step towards socialism.Socialism is defined by Merriam-Webster as:
A way of organizing a society in which major industries are owned and controlled by the government rather than by individual people and companies. When I read this it does not seem like it implies that the government should stand by while millions of citizens are denied or unable to afford health care. It doesn't seem to imply that feeding the hungry will somehow lead to the downfall of society. The government is not looking to own or control major industries. Instead it is forced to regulate, restrict and dictate how they operate so that they do not treat people as miserable as possible in an effort to make every last inch of profit.
The President Signing the Act

The Affordable Care Act
In 2013, the Congress passed the Affordable Care Act also referred to as Obamacare. Sadly it was a departure from what many of us hoped which was a single payer system. Single-payer health care is a system in which the government, rather than private insurers, pays for all health care costs. Instead the government approved the act which mad health care mandatory for all citizens and provided options for people that could previously not get approved for health care. Despite all of this assistance, health insurance still may not be affordable for some. "What it means for something to be affordable or not affordable is totally debatable," said Sherry Glied, dean of New York University's Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service. "It isn't like there's a fixed definition of affordability." There are still Republicans that are fighting to appeal this act and in reality it is not far enough. These people make it sound like this is the end of our society when in reality it is only a small step towards what Eleanor Roosevelt had envisioned as the right thing to do so long ago.

Moving Forward
I personally have hope that the public that is benefiting from this and the people that realize this is the right thing to do will not allow Republicans to repeal this. Hopefully this will lead people to realize that this is not something dangerous and instead something that helps people and is right. Maybe one day a single payer system will make it truly affordable and accessible to all. My family has suffered from the ridiculous state of the healthcare system and I refuse to believe that the goodness in people will not allow the system to evolve over time to a point where we can fully adopt the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and realize a concept that seemed so obvious to a group of smart individuals so long ago.


Works Cited

Ollove, Michael. "Is Affordable Care Act Really Affordable for All?" USA Today. Gannett, 14 Jan. 2014. Web. 23 Jan. 2014.

"Single-payer Health Care." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 22 Jan. 2014. Web. 24 Jan. 2014.

"Socialism." Merriam-Webster. Merriam-Webster, n.d. Web. 22 Jan. 2014.

"The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, UDHR, Declaration of Human Rights, Human Rights Declaration, Human Rights Charter, The Un and Human Rights." UN News Center. UN, n.d. Web. 23 Jan. 2014.

Thursday, January 16, 2014

Christians Continue to Limit the Civil Rights of Others



The World War I obsession with “100 percent Americanism” continued in the 1920s and led to a resurgence of the Ku Klux Klan. This group of predominately white Protestant Christians believed that American freedom should be limited based on religion and ethnicity. This new Klan attacked a far broader array of targets including anything they viewed as endangering individual liberty including immigrant Jews and Catholics. Still to this day Christians in America display many of the same ignorant behaviors towards gays, the poor and other religions. 

Danger with Radical Views
The Ku Klux Klan in the early twenties had ignorant radical views that were only shared by a portion of the country. However, when radical views are tolerated and present they make other less radical ideas seem acceptable. The beliefs and viewpoints of the members of this movement reflected and influenced the actions taken later in the 1920s to limit who had the right or privilege to become an American. For example, in 1924 Congress passed a law limiting European immigration to 150,000 per year. In many ways they succeeded in marginalizing a large group of people. 

The Klan's Tactics
Example of Tactics Used
With political leaders in their membership the Klan was able to not only strike fear in their victims but it also was able to pass laws to institute restrictions on these groups. They showed their allegiance to their faith through church attendance, speeches and writings and the recruitment of ministers as members. Visiting churches to make monetary donations was another method used by Klan members to show their commitment. (Baker) Anti-Klan lecturer and author W.C. Witcher denounced the Klan’s claims to 100% Americanism, he feared the Klan would damage Christianity, arguing “If the Klan is a religious organization it will destroy the Christian religion, unless it is destroyed itself.” Even with this opposition in Oregon the Klan drove the passage of a law outlawing private schools. This was targeted at the Roman Catholic Church which maintained separate schools. In an effort to display their “Americanism” the Church urged their immigrant members to learn English and embrace “American principles”. Even though the Klan would soon fall out of prominence it had established a on-going Christian-bully theme of using tactics like this to limit other group's freedom to live their lives as they see fit. It also introduced the tactic of presenting themselves as martyrs for causes like improving American or defending values.



The Supreme Court Involvement
Justice James C. McReynolds
In Meyer v Nebraska, Justice McReynolds stated in the ruling: “The protection of the Constitution extends to all, to those who speak other languages as well as to those born with English on the tongue.” (U.S. Supreme Court 2). This decision would have ideally put an end to this type of discrimination. This unfortunately has not proven to be the case. Instead today we see Christians more often becoming the aggressors. They force their views and beliefs on everyone and usually claim something about "core values". In the
The Current Supreme Court
town of Greece, NY for the last eight years the town council meetings are started with a prayer delivered only by Christian clergy, who sometimes asked attendees to stand and bow their heads, and frequently invoked Jesus and the Holy Spirit (Markoe). Two town residents of the town residents, a Jewish woman and an atheist sued over the prayers and lost in federal court in 2011, arguing that the town had violated the Constitution’s Establishment Clause, which prohibits government-sponsored religion. But they won in 2012 at the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which ruled that the town’s approach to public prayer amounted to an endorsement of Christianity. The Christians are trying to argue that it is their First Amendment right to say whatever they desire. If the ruling is held up by the Supreme Court there will no doubt be threats to the Justices and the plaintiffs much like Justice McReynolds endured after his decision. Its sad that Christians feel the need to impose their beliefs in a forum that offends other non-believers and on top it they try to claim that it is their right.

Making Progress?
While I would hope we'd be making progress against this type of behavior, it seems that it is still present in too many places. Just a few days ago the president of the anti-gay National Organization for Marriage asked the Supreme Court to delay the implementation of Utah's new same sex marriage act to “slow the stampede of rabid same-sex marriage bullies who are willing to trample over the rights of everyone else in order to get their way. There’s no telling how many true constitutional rights these radicals would run roughshod over to gain their prize of a faux right to genderless ‘marriage’ and a regime under which Christians and others are relegated to second-class citizen status.” (Reed). I read these things and ask myself if this is for real and how anyone could be this ignorant. Even worse, they are now trying to paint themselves as a
Protestors gather during Minnesota's Senate marriage equality vote
victim to the people they have been victimizing. If it wasn't so sad it would be funny. Despite the setbacks there is some glimmer of hope. On May 14, 2012 in Minnesota, Gov. Mark Dayton signed a bill allowing same-sex marriage. Republicians had placed this measure on the ballet hoping to bring out a strong Christian following to elect more GOP officials, in a surprising turn this did the opposite and brought out many Democrats to deny it and flipped the balance of power in the state.Ideally this will become a trend and continue. While we may always have a group of people that feel that behavior and actions to limit civil rights and freedom of other people is acceptable, hopefully we can have a louder majority that ignores these statements and rises up to make sure they are not tolerated.



Works Cited

     Sept. 2011. Web. 16 Jan. 2014.

     Meetings" Religion News Service. N.p., 06 Nov. 2013. Web. 16 Jan. 2014. 

Osler, Mark. "The End of Bully Christianity." Sojourners. N.p., 22 May 2013. Web. 17 Jan. 2014. 

     N.p., 09 Jan. 2014. Web. 17 Jan. 2014.

     Legacy, 02 Aug. 2009. Web. 16 Jan. 2014.

Thursday, January 9, 2014

Treatment of African American Voters during the 1890's is sadly familiar to recent elections


The South After the War
Labored with difficult circumstances, things remained very difficult for African Americans after the Civil War in the South. The rapid job growth in the industrial economy of the North was not a reasonable escape. The Northern companies preferred to hire white migrants from rural areas and immigrants from Europe. Living in these conditions caused hardship, embarrassment and a great deal of fear. The actions taken by whites during this time were some of the most barbaric of any culture throughout history. These spanned from physical violence to a complete campaign to drive blacks into a secondary class of citizens. Sadly, although to a different degree, with the recent economic problems the United States witnessed some of these similar actions during the election of 2012.
http://polination.wordpress.com/
http://adamcuerden.deviantart.com

During the period of Reconstruction blacks enjoyed increased participation in politics with some serving in Congress. Sadly after laws made this more difficult it took nearly 100 years to get participation levels back to where they were during this time. This was even more impressive because this was the same time period where ironically the Democrats (later we'll discuss how it is now the Republicans using these tactics) introduced a series of laws intended to suppress the black vote. One of the most popular mechanisms was a poll tax where voters had to pay to retain the right to vote. Many also made literacy a requirement to vote which at first cost them many white votes so they further made it specific to blacks by introducing a grandfather clause which excluded people who were or descended from people that had the right to vote prior to the Civil War. While this sounds completely ridiculous to me, there were a number of similar proposals done during the 2012 election.


Similar Tactics Almost 100 Year Later
http://colorlines.com/
    During the election season of 2012 there were numerous states and districts which introduced laws to suppress minority vote, Florida was one of the worst offenders. Republican governor Rick Scott started a voter purge which he claimed identified non-citizens who were not eligible to vote. Upon inspection by an outside group it was determined that at least 500 of the roughly 2700 people were actually citizens (Weiner). 
Voters waiting in long lines.
Another tactic used was reducing early voting days. The claim was that this would cut down on the instances of fraud (about as likely as getting hit by lightening). In reality this was done so that voting could not be done on the weekend prior to the election. This is because blacks and many other minorities have traditionally voted on Sundays after church or other social gathers so they could car pool or take buses to polling locations because many of them do not have their own transportation (Froomkin). The governor also signed a law which enforced a 48-hour deadline for organizations to deliver applications to a voter-registration offices to limit new voter registrations that officials feared would be predominately young people and minorities (Reilly). Finally, the number of voting locations was significantly reduced so people needed to stand in lines for more than 6 hours to vote in certain districts. After the election former GOP chairman and former Gov. Charlie Crist, both of who were ousted from the party, said that voter fraud concerns were used to explain the law hid the main purpose of GOP victory (Kam and Lantigua).

The Real Reason Behind These Actions
     I believe that these two time periods share a common theme. In both instances white people were facing challenging economic times and in both instances the government seemed to lead them into believing that it was the fault of the minorities. I believe this was done for two reasons. The first reason was to take the focus off shortcomings of the government. The Farmer's Alliance formed on a general belief that government wasn't doing enough to control the railroad's freight rates, the interest rates on loans or mitigate the effects of a reduced money supply. This was a legitimate challenge of the government's authority so then this led to the second reason which was that these laws split the citizens into two groups in essence splitting their opposition in half. The poor whites started to care more about keeping the blacks down. In reality, if they worked together against the government then they could have gotten much more accomplished. Today, we see this to even a larger degree. Issues separate people on race, sexual preference and religion. This division has led our government to an almost complete standstill. Interesting enough it is the Republicans who now drive that division because they are desperately trying to hang onto whatever power then can. This is exactly what the Democrats were doing in the late 19th century when they regularly raised the threat of "Negro domination" to justify the denial of the right to vote.

Looking Forward
     It is sad to believe that in the last 100 years we have progressed so little in some areas but I have hope that as a society we will begin to realize that working together will always help us progress. Dividing ourselves will never be the answer to improving any of our lives. I will never understand why people believe that belittling or marginalizing a particular group would help them in any way. While this is happening in a particular section of the country we are all responsible for ending this type of behavior. The South was the root of this behavior in the 1890's but none of this would have been allowed if the North didn't go along with it. So while this behavior is not present in California we have a responsibility to fight against it.





Works Cited

Froomkin, Dan. "Republican Voter Suppression Campaign Rolls Back Early Voting." The Huffington 
     Post. TheHuffingtonPost.com, 18 Aug. 2012. Web. 09 Jan. 2014.

Kam, Dara, and John Lantigua. "Former Florida GOP Leaders Say Voter Suppression Was Reason 
     They Pushed New Election Law." Former Florida GOP Leaders Say Voter Suppression Was 
     Reason... N.p., 25 Nov. 2012. Web. 09 Jan. 2014.

Reilly, Ryan J. "Federal Judge Blocks, Skewers Florida's Third-Party Voter Registration 
     Restrictions." Talking Points Memo. N.p., 31 May 2012. Web. 09 Jan. 2014.

Weiner, Rachel. "Florida’s Voter Purge Explained." Washington Post. The Washington Post, 18 June
     2012. Web. 09 Jan. 2014.