Thursday, January 9, 2014

Treatment of African American Voters during the 1890's is sadly familiar to recent elections


The South After the War
Labored with difficult circumstances, things remained very difficult for African Americans after the Civil War in the South. The rapid job growth in the industrial economy of the North was not a reasonable escape. The Northern companies preferred to hire white migrants from rural areas and immigrants from Europe. Living in these conditions caused hardship, embarrassment and a great deal of fear. The actions taken by whites during this time were some of the most barbaric of any culture throughout history. These spanned from physical violence to a complete campaign to drive blacks into a secondary class of citizens. Sadly, although to a different degree, with the recent economic problems the United States witnessed some of these similar actions during the election of 2012.
http://polination.wordpress.com/
http://adamcuerden.deviantart.com

During the period of Reconstruction blacks enjoyed increased participation in politics with some serving in Congress. Sadly after laws made this more difficult it took nearly 100 years to get participation levels back to where they were during this time. This was even more impressive because this was the same time period where ironically the Democrats (later we'll discuss how it is now the Republicans using these tactics) introduced a series of laws intended to suppress the black vote. One of the most popular mechanisms was a poll tax where voters had to pay to retain the right to vote. Many also made literacy a requirement to vote which at first cost them many white votes so they further made it specific to blacks by introducing a grandfather clause which excluded people who were or descended from people that had the right to vote prior to the Civil War. While this sounds completely ridiculous to me, there were a number of similar proposals done during the 2012 election.


Similar Tactics Almost 100 Year Later
http://colorlines.com/
    During the election season of 2012 there were numerous states and districts which introduced laws to suppress minority vote, Florida was one of the worst offenders. Republican governor Rick Scott started a voter purge which he claimed identified non-citizens who were not eligible to vote. Upon inspection by an outside group it was determined that at least 500 of the roughly 2700 people were actually citizens (Weiner). 
Voters waiting in long lines.
Another tactic used was reducing early voting days. The claim was that this would cut down on the instances of fraud (about as likely as getting hit by lightening). In reality this was done so that voting could not be done on the weekend prior to the election. This is because blacks and many other minorities have traditionally voted on Sundays after church or other social gathers so they could car pool or take buses to polling locations because many of them do not have their own transportation (Froomkin). The governor also signed a law which enforced a 48-hour deadline for organizations to deliver applications to a voter-registration offices to limit new voter registrations that officials feared would be predominately young people and minorities (Reilly). Finally, the number of voting locations was significantly reduced so people needed to stand in lines for more than 6 hours to vote in certain districts. After the election former GOP chairman and former Gov. Charlie Crist, both of who were ousted from the party, said that voter fraud concerns were used to explain the law hid the main purpose of GOP victory (Kam and Lantigua).

The Real Reason Behind These Actions
     I believe that these two time periods share a common theme. In both instances white people were facing challenging economic times and in both instances the government seemed to lead them into believing that it was the fault of the minorities. I believe this was done for two reasons. The first reason was to take the focus off shortcomings of the government. The Farmer's Alliance formed on a general belief that government wasn't doing enough to control the railroad's freight rates, the interest rates on loans or mitigate the effects of a reduced money supply. This was a legitimate challenge of the government's authority so then this led to the second reason which was that these laws split the citizens into two groups in essence splitting their opposition in half. The poor whites started to care more about keeping the blacks down. In reality, if they worked together against the government then they could have gotten much more accomplished. Today, we see this to even a larger degree. Issues separate people on race, sexual preference and religion. This division has led our government to an almost complete standstill. Interesting enough it is the Republicans who now drive that division because they are desperately trying to hang onto whatever power then can. This is exactly what the Democrats were doing in the late 19th century when they regularly raised the threat of "Negro domination" to justify the denial of the right to vote.

Looking Forward
     It is sad to believe that in the last 100 years we have progressed so little in some areas but I have hope that as a society we will begin to realize that working together will always help us progress. Dividing ourselves will never be the answer to improving any of our lives. I will never understand why people believe that belittling or marginalizing a particular group would help them in any way. While this is happening in a particular section of the country we are all responsible for ending this type of behavior. The South was the root of this behavior in the 1890's but none of this would have been allowed if the North didn't go along with it. So while this behavior is not present in California we have a responsibility to fight against it.





Works Cited

Froomkin, Dan. "Republican Voter Suppression Campaign Rolls Back Early Voting." The Huffington 
     Post. TheHuffingtonPost.com, 18 Aug. 2012. Web. 09 Jan. 2014.

Kam, Dara, and John Lantigua. "Former Florida GOP Leaders Say Voter Suppression Was Reason 
     They Pushed New Election Law." Former Florida GOP Leaders Say Voter Suppression Was 
     Reason... N.p., 25 Nov. 2012. Web. 09 Jan. 2014.

Reilly, Ryan J. "Federal Judge Blocks, Skewers Florida's Third-Party Voter Registration 
     Restrictions." Talking Points Memo. N.p., 31 May 2012. Web. 09 Jan. 2014.

Weiner, Rachel. "Florida’s Voter Purge Explained." Washington Post. The Washington Post, 18 June
     2012. Web. 09 Jan. 2014.

No comments:

Post a Comment